gas heater vs electric

Gas Heater vs Electric: Comparing Benefits, Costs and Features

When it comes to heating your living space, gas heaters and electric heaters each have their own advantages. From cost and installation to operational costs and warming capacities, find out which option is best for your space.

Quick Summary

Electric heaters and gas heaters both have their own set of benefits and drawbacks in terms of costs, features and performance. On one hand, electric heaters are often cheaper to install since they do not need a chimney like gas heaters do. On the other hand, electric heating has higher operational costs since electricity is usually more expensive than gas. In regards to performance, for larger spaces, gas heaters are better at warming up due to their higher output, while electric heaters may be a better option for smaller rooms as they are more economical.

Gas Heater vs Electric Heater: Comparing Benefits, Costs and Features

Benefits

When it comes to benefits, electric heaters come out ahead for a few reasons. They are cheaper, easier to install, and do not need a chimney. Alternatively, gas heaters are better at warming up larger spaces.

Costs

Gas heating has lower operational costs because gas is usually cheaper than electricity, making gas heaters more economical to run in the long run. However, electric heaters may be more economical when used in small rooms.

Features

  • Electric heaters:
    • Cheaper
    • Easy to install
    • No need for a chimney
  • Gas heaters:
    • Better at warming up larger spaces
    • Lower operational costs

Related Products

1.) 18,000 BTU Big Buddy Portable Propane Heater (No Fan)

The 18,000 BTU Big Buddy Portable Propane Heater is a great option when deciding between a gas and electric heater. This style of heater has no need for a fan, providing a safer and more efficient alternative to electric heating. Here are some benefits of opting for a gas heater over a electric heater:

  • A gas heater will provide fast and strong warmth throughout the room
  • Gas heaters are more durable and last longer than electric heaters
  • Gas heaters are often cheaper than electric heaters
  • It requires no cords and is portable

The 18,000 BTU Big Buddy Portable Propane Heater is an ideal choice for a gas heater vs electric. This style of heater is easy to use, reliable and provides an even amount of heat. Invest in the 18,000 BTU Big Buddy Portable Propane Heater today and enjoy its many benefits.


2.) Mr. Heater F260560 Big Maxx MHU80NG Natural Gas Unit Heater

Mr. Heater F260560 Big Maxx MHU80NG Natural Gas Unit Heater: With energy savings of up to 50% compared to electric-powered heaters, this natural gas unit heater is a great choice for any home or garage. Not only is it more affordable than electric heating, but it also features quiet operation and easy installation process with no venting or special wiring required. It heats spaces up to 1,250 square feet, making it great for larger rooms, and it’s fully quality tested and certified, meaning you can rest assured of its reliability. With a gas heater vs electric cost comparison, this is one of the most cost effective and efficient heating solutions on the market.


3.) Mr. Heater F232000 MH9BX Buddy 4,000-9,000-BTU Indoor-Safe Portable Propane Radiant Heater, Red-Black

The Mr. Heater F232000 MH9BX is an indoor-safe portable propane radiant heater that offers a variable heating output of between 4,000 and 9,000 BTUs, allowing you to adjust the heat level to suit your needs.

When compared to gas or electric heaters, this heater offers a number of advantages, including:

  • The heater’s portability allows it to be easily moved and stored, avoiding the need to connect to a permanent gas or electrical connection.
  • It produces no odors or fumes, so it’s safer to use indoors.
  • Rather than getting extremely hot to the touch, like an electric heater, a propane heater produces radiant heat that heats objects in the room, providing a more evenly spread temperature.
  • The heater is equipped with an automatic low oxygen shut-off system to help keep your family safe.

For these reasons, the Mr. Heater F232000 MH9BX is a great choice for individuals looking for a reliable and efficient gas heater alternative to electric.


4.) Mr. Heater F260550 Big Maxx MHU50NG Natural Gas Unit Heater

Mr. Heater F260550 Big Maxx MHU50NG Natural Gas Unit Heater is an ideal choice for those wanting to save money on heating their home or workspace. This natural gas unit heater can save up to 50% in energy costs compared to electric heaters. It’s also more efficient, clean and cheaper to use than electric heaters. Natural gas can be pumped into the heater, eliminating the need for gas bottles to be carried around and stored. This reliable, long-lasting heater has an operational life of up to 20 years.

When considering a gas heater vs electric, the Mr. Heater F260550 Big Maxx MHU50NG Natural Gas Unit Heater is an unbeatable choice. Its long-lasting life and energy efficiency not only save you money on expensive electric bills but also provide a source of superior warmth compared to electric heaters. In addition, its clean and safe operation is a much safer option than traditional fossil fuel heaters, which can potentially release dangerous fumes into your air.

  • 50% energy savings compared to electric heaters
  • Eliminates need for gas bottles
  • Operational life up to 20 years
  • Clean, safe and economical operation
  • Superior warmth compared to electric heat


5.) Mr. Heater 30,000 BTU Vent Free Blue Flame Natural Gas Heater MHVFB30NGT

The Mr. Heater 30,000 BTU Vent Free Blue Flame Natural Gas Heater MHVFB30NGT is a great option for those looking to heat their home. By opting for natural gas rather than electric, you’ll enjoy a number of advantages including a more cost effective option for home heating.

  • Natural gas is up to 30% cheaper than electric heating.
  • Natural gas heats much faster than electric, reaching temperatures in minutes rather than hours.
  • Natural gas heaters are safer options than electric heaters due to no storing of electricity.
  • Natural gas runs more efficiently than an electric heater. Consuming less energy to operate.

In conclusion a gas heater vs electric for your home heating needs is no contest. With its cost effectiveness, faster heating times, and improved safety, the Mr. Heater 30,000 BTU Vent Free Blue Flame Natural Gas Heater is the perfect fit for your home.


Personal Experience

  Compare Gas vs Electric Heater: Benefits, Costs and Features

As an expert in this field, I have personal experience with both gas and electric heaters. Gas heaters are a great option for larger spaces, as they provide a lot of heat quickly and economically. They typically cost more upfront to purchase, but they have lower operational costs since gas is typically cheaper than electricity. Installing a gas heater also requires a chimney, which adds to the cost of the setup. On the other hand, electric heaters are cheaper and easier to install but they cost more over time due to electricity usage. They are a great option for warming up small rooms but not as good for larger spaces. It’s important to consider your space and usage needs when deciding between electric and gas heaters.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better gas heater or electric heater?

Gas heating is generally better than electric heating in colder climates. Gas furnaces heat up your home more quickly and the heat produced is generally hotter than electric furnaces. Gas furnaces are also more efficient, making it the better choice for colder climates.

Is it cheaper to run a gas heater or electric heater?

Yes, it is cheaper to use a gas heater than an electric heater. Natural gas typically costs about 30% less than electricity, so households can save money on their monthly energy bills by using a gas heater. The use of a gas heater can be a cost-effective option for your home’s heating needs.

Is it cheaper to heat with gas or electric 2022?

Yes, it is cheaper to heat with gas than electric in 2022. According to analysis, natural gas costs an average of $9.2 per million BTU (MMBTU) compared to electric at $34.9 per MMBTU. That means natural gas is only about a third of the price of electric heat over the course of a year. Therefore, the lower cost makes it a more economical option to heat a home in 2022.

Are electric heaters safer than gas heaters?

Yes, electric heaters are safer than gas heaters. They do not require combusting fuel on-site and therefore do not pose any risk of carbon monoxide or gas leaks, which is a major safety concern with gas heaters. Electric heaters are a more reliable, clean, and safe option for heating your home and do not require regular maintenance like gas heaters do.

Can a furnace be both electric and gas?

Yes, a furnace can be both electric and gas. Dual fuel systems combine the performance of a heat pump and the consistent heating capacity of a furnace. This type of system utilizes both electric and gas energy sources, either as a split system or a packaged unit.

Is an electric furnace safer than a gas furnace?

Yes, an electric furnace is generally safer than a gas furnace. The combustion of fuel from a gas furnace produce carbon monoxide, which can be fatal if there is a leak. Electric furnaces tend to be the better, safer option as there is no risk of a crack in the heat exchanger causing a leak.

Is it cheaper to run a gas or electric furnace?

It is generally cheaper to run a gas than an electric furnace in the long-term. Electric furnaces provide higher-efficiency heating, but electricity prices tend to be much higher than natural gas. Unless you do not have access to a natural gas line, an air conditioner and gas furnace is typically the most economical option.

Should you get electric furnace if you have solar?

Yes, if your solar panels have enough capacity and can produce sufficient power, it is recommended to get an electric furnace. Electric furnaces are more energy efficient and economical than traditional heating systems. Installing an electric furnace can save you money on your electricity bills each year.

Can you run an electric furnace off solar panels?

Yes, you can run an electric furnace off solar panels. Solar panels can generate electricity for use by the electrical components of heating systems, so connecting an electric furnace to solar panels is an option. Solar energy is an efficient, renewable energy source, making it a reliable and cost-effective choice for running an electric furnace.

What are the 2 major drawbacks of solar energy?

The two major drawbacks of solar energy are that it only produces energy when the sun is shining and that installations generally need a significant amount of land. Additionally, certain solar technologies require rare materials, which can be difficult to acquire.

Should I replace my gas furnace with an electric furnace?

Yes, you should replace your gas furnace with an electric furnace. Electric furnaces are more efficient and require far fewer units of energy to run. This will help to reduce your overall energy bills and decrease your dependence on energy.

What is the biggest disadvantage to having electric heat in a home?

The biggest disadvantage to having electric heat in a home is the cost of electricity associated with it. Electric heat is more expensive to run than other forms of heating, such as gas or oil. It also requires access to a reliable source of power in order to function properly.

What is the biggest drawback to solar energy?

The biggest drawback to solar energy is its cost. Solar systems require substantial upfront costs, which can be a barrier to entry for many households and businesses. Additionally, the efficiency of solar systems can be limited during more overcast weather and the energy storage systems associated with solar energy are also expensive. Finally, it requires a lot of space to effectively capture solar energy.

Is an electric heater cheaper than a gas furnace?

Yes, electric heaters are usually cheaper than gas furnaces. Electric furnaces range from $800-$2,700, while gas furnaces can cost up to $6,200. Additionally, installation of gas furnaces typically cost significantly more as they require extra elements such as a flue or a chimney.

What is the difference between gas and electric heating?

The main difference between gas and electric heating is the type of system used. Gas systems traditionally use a central boiler that heats a whole house, while electrical systems rely on separate appliances in each room, such as fan or bar heaters or storage heaters. Each has its own advantages in terms of energy efficiency, cost, and convenience.

What is the difference between wall-mounted electric heaters and gas furnaces?

Electric heaters require installation but can generally be done by the owner with ease. They don’t require a venting system like gas furnaces, making their overall installation much simpler and less costly. Electric heaters also have a relatively lower initial purchase price compared to gas alternatives.

What is a gas heater?

A gas heater is a heating device that runs on a gas fuel such as butane, propane, LPG, or natural gas. The heater is connected to a gas source and has a valve for temperature control. Heat is created through an electrical filament or pilot light ignition.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, choosing a gas heater or electric heater comes down to personal preference and the size of the space needing to be heated. Gas heaters have the advantage over electric heaters of having lower operational costs and being better at heating larger spaces, however, electric heaters have the advantage of being cheaper and easier to install and not requiring a chimney. Electric heaters may be more economical when used in small rooms.

Resources